Product Review: Makin’s Clay Professional Ultimate Clay Machine

1 Star 1 star (out of 5)

Suggested Retail Price: $50 – $60

Makin’s® Clay is on version 2 of the Ultimate Clay Machine. Unfortunately, their 2nd try solves one problem and creates another.

In April 2006, Makin’s Clay stopped production of its Ultimate Clay Machine. This new machine initially showed real promise. It was the only commercial “pasta” machine that touted non-stick rollers, wider rolling area (around 7″), and 9 thickness settings. No other machine had the same unique features.

It’s unfortunate that these unique features have caused great headaches for the Makin’s people. The way that pasta machines…er…clay machines work is that clay is rolled between two rollers. Below the rollers, “scrapers” keep the clay from continuing round and round the rollers–they scrape the clay off the rollers and the clay comes extrudes out below. The scraper blades are made of metal and are fairly sharp, and they tend to touch the rollers to ensure that material doesn’t continue to stick on the rollers.

This core design was troublesome for the 1st Makin’s machine. When the scraper blades touched the non-stick coated rollers, they scraped grooves into the non-stick coating at the points of contact. And when you rolled your clay through, those light grooves translated into grooves and texture onto your clay. The grooves were minor, but you could see them clearly on the rollers, and lightly on the clay.

This grooving happened to me on the very first use of the original machine. I contacted the vendor who sold me the machine, and she refunded my money. Walnut Hollow, the US distributor of the Makin’s Machine (the machine is manufactured by Hong-Kong based Sino Harvest Limited), picked up the machine via FedEx at their cost.

I thought this was the end of it, but Walnut Hollow mistakenly sent me the version 2 machine a few weeks ago. Being the curious sort that I am, I decided to test the machine. First, I read the instructions, and cleaned the machine as advised. I then took some black Kato Polyclay that I conditioned in my Atlas machine, and ran it through the #1 setting of the Makin’s Machine. I immediately noticed a scraping across the top surface of the clay–as if I had scraped a wide object across the clay and marred the surface. I folded the clay and ran it through #1 a couple of times and noticed the same scraping. This was a bad sign.

At #2, there was still scraping. At #3, more still. At #4, I had a piece of clay that was rippled on the top, with fairly deep ripples but no tearing. This rippling got worse as I set the machine thinner. This wasn’t going well.

I cleaned the machine and tried with some unconditioned clay–maybe my clay was too soft. I took some unconditioned black Kato Polyclay and flattened it with my acrylic roller. I put it through a #1 and saw the top scraping. I conditioned it on #1, folding and rolling as usual. Still some marring. And when it was getting conditioned and as I rolled it through successively thinner settings, the same rippling occurred. I also tried with some softer clay, some metallic clay, etc. The result was the same.

I turned the machine over and found the culprit–they had replaced the metal scrapers with plastic, and it was apparent that the polymer clay was sticking to or scraping against the plastic. The friction from this plastic on plastic is causing the surface marring at #1 and the rippling at #4 and beyond. HOWEVER, and this is a big HOWEVER, not everyone that has been using the new machine has experienced the same issues as I have. BUT some others have.

I contacted Walnut Hollow regarding the error and regarding the issues with the clay, and they once again sent FedEx to pick up the machine. They also sent me a technical sheet regarding use of the machine. The thing to note is this. Makin’s clearly states, “The Ultimate Clay Machine™ works best with Makin’s ® Clay. Results may vary if machine is used with brands of clay other than Makin’s Clay. Because we have no control over the manufacturing and distribution process of clays other than the Makin’s ® brand (including but not limited to ingredients; formula; nor storage, shipping or handling methods), we cannot guarantee the quality or consistency of results you may experience using the machine with other clay brands. Your results may vary depending on brand of clay used. The information on this technical sheet is presented in good faith, but no warranty is given, nor results guaranteed.

The net of it? Well, my old Atlas was abused through some very rough handling by the USPS when I sent it to and from my vacation spot. I was hoping to replace it with the Makin’s machine, but given my experience with 2 poor designs, I’m going back to the Atlas. The Atlas 180 has the wider (7″) rolling surface and 9 thickness settings. All it doesn’t have is the non-stick rollers. Given that Makin’s is suggesting the use of cornstarch, deli sheets or waxed paper in case of sticking when rolling thin sheets–the things we do with the regular steel rollers without a non-stick coating–and given that the prices of the Atlas 180 and the Makin’s machines are relatively the same, there is no advantage, and some risk, in purchasing the Makin’s machine for use with anything other than Makin’s Clay.



Filed under 1 Star, Products, Tools

8 responses to “Product Review: Makin’s Clay Professional Ultimate Clay Machine

  1. So true. Makin’s is a nice company, but this is just an awful product. I have thrown two away before their recall and I don’t see the point using this machine. To Makin’s credit, they did refund my money and bend over backwards to please me. The product just won’t cut it.
    If you want an easy to clean, high quality machine that is a workhorse I advise getting the Atlas 180 modified by Mona Kissel’s husband (that would be “Monafied”) available through her website:, under Tools.

  2. blythespirited

    So true, so true. I never should have thrown out my old Amaco machine…true, it had its issues, but the clay never ever rippled or tore or got stuck anywhere. Now, the local craft stores have nothing but the Makins model. What should have been a great boon to the clay community has turned out to be a massive ripoff.

  3. Lynn O'Connor

    I had the same problems with the Makins’ machine. It clearly is intended for air-dry clay, not for polymer clay. It took too long to resolve this problem. Makins first asked me to try a replacement machine; I was reluctant because I suspected the problem is in the design of the machine, but I did agree. The second machine quickly developed the same problem as the first – severe rippling at finer settings, and I returned it. Makins had assured me they would resolve the situation to my satisfaction, but, now that I’ve returned both machines, they’ve emailed me to tell me there is no defect in their machine and they won’t refund my money. Fortunately, I’ve already received my refund from my supplier, PrairieCraft, who have been helpful and professional throughout this process. The bottom line is that this machine, and its maker, have a disappointing record.

  4. Gail

    Thanks for the detailed review. I was considering buying this machine, but now I won’t. I appreciate the review from a person who has used it. Gail

  5. I was looking at this machine as well. Guess I’ll pass now. I really would like a nice pasta machine but they’re so stinking expensive. The acrylic rollers and hand rollers in general just don’t work so well, especially for my young kids. I’d love that part of the process to be much easier for them. For now I just have them roll the beads and it’s good for their motor skills anyway. If anyone has advice on a somewhat inexpensive but useful and goodt quality tool for rolling polymer clay beads please say so!

  6. Jane

    Within 30 days I was sorry I bought this piece of crap, it loads itself up with clay behind the rollers and impedes the rollers, then leaves groves in the clay. Save your $50.00 and get a Atlas Pasta machine my old one was 30 years old before it fell apart.

  7. cheryl sayers

    I wish I had read this BEFORE I bought the unit. I admit I was blinded by the mulitible setting for the machine and my 40% coupon.
    The first one didn’t work on the lower settings at all. It jammed every time. I returned to place of purchase and found another at a different location and it seemed fine- at first. Now it’s being a problem at the number 1 setting, but the others are fine. I was going to resell my 30 year old pasta machine- but now I think not.. The construction of the top of the Makins machine is way to light for the price of the unit. If I had to do over again, I would go with a different machine. This one may still go back.

  8. Thank you – I have just found the updated model at a special offer price….so I am glad I found your review before ordering!
    Great site, by the way!!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s